Let me start by saying this is strictly my opinion of products. NOT the people who sell them. Also...it's an opinion. I'm not an expert (obvi).
Now that I have your attention...
Hi there.
People ask me all the time what steps I've taken to lose all this weight and get heathier this year.
When I tell them, "clean eating and LOTS of exercise," the vast majority of them stand there, waiting for me to continue speaking. When I don't, they invariably ask...
"No supplements?"
"No meal replacements?"
No. None of that stuff.
Actual, factual food, and real, hard work. Boom. End of story.
When they then ask why I don't use Shakeology/Isagenix/Advocare/Herbalife, my response is invariably say this:
1) I'm doing fantastic without it.
2) most of them suck and aren't really that healthy
3) I'm not a fan of MLM in general
4) I don't want to pay for something that I feel has no value
I have a science background. Buzzwords don't get me excited. Facts do.
 |
| If this is the healthiest meal of your day, I'd hate to see what kind of crap you're eating the rest of the day. |
 |
| You know what else builds champions? Hard work. |
 |
| No comment. |
 |
| Their logo is green, so it has to be healthy...right? |
Now, I know I just raised a lot of hackles. Like half the people I know from the gym are slaves to Isagenix. An online fitness group I participate in is on the Shakeology train. I have co-workers who sell and use Herbalife, and relatives that sell and use Advocare. Universally, people who use this type of product are fanatically devoted to it. And that's cool...whatever floats your boat!
I just don't feel any of it is necessary, or healthy.
Here is why.
Exhibit A:
http://www.ancestral-nutrition.com/an-unbiased-review-of-herbalife/
Exhibit B:
http://www.ancestral-nutrition.com/unbiased-review-shakeology/
Exhibit C:
http://www.ancestral-nutrition.com/an-unbiased-review-of-isagenix/
Exhibit D:
http://www.ancestral-nutrition.com/an-unbiased-review-of-advocare/
Please read the one(s) that pertain to you. I'll wait here.
Ok, now that you've read the one(s) that pertain to you and are armed with a billion reasons why X-brand shake and bar and vitamins are the best thing ever, let me lay this on you...
I am aware that Dani's research is imperfect. However, it's the first research I've seen that wasn't funded and published by the company selling the product.
I've seen dozens upon dozens of articles touting the awesomeness of these products. I've seen Facebook links to information about their "nutritional quality." 100% of these articles and links have been directly from the company itself.
That's not research, guys.
That's propaganda.
And after every article about the "nutritional quality" are testimonials. Sometimes the testimonials are from happy customers. SOMETIMES THEY ARE FROM PEOPLE WHO'VE MADE A LOT OF MONEY PEDDLING THIS STUFF. Red flag, yo. The people I know that sell and use these products are good people...but it's easy to see how some shady characters could take serious advantage of people. This is why I don't like MLM.
I've also had a lot of conversations with friends saying, "Well, X-brand may not be perfect, but it's better than Y-brand."
Being the best out of a category of not great things is still not good.
I think the number one reason why these products piss me off is this...
Many of them are officially called "meal replacement" items, but are heavily marketed as weight loss items. "Slimcakes?" "Isalean?" "Advocare: We build champions?" Come on. Tell me that's not pushing overweight people to drop ten tons of money on snacks and shakes filled with chemicals, sugars, and GMOs, with a few "organic superfoods" thrown in to make the package wording sound appealing.
Every health professional I've talked to (not fitness professionals, heath professionals...nurses, doctors, chiropractors, and nutritionists) has told me they would never recommend this stuff to their clients or patients. They do admit they've had patients who've lost weight using these products, but the vast majority have gained it back, plus some, once they stop the system.
And don't even get me started on cleanses. Unless you have renal disease or liver failure, or for some reason, your body doesn't sweat, poop, or pee, I'm pretty sure Mother Nature designed your body to effectively "cleanse" itself without any outside help or starving.
I'm going to go ahead and read some of your minds right now...
Uh, Angie, WTF makes you such an expert?
You've only been "living this lifestyle" for like a year, what do you know?
Have you ever even TRIED these products?
Not an expert, just sharing my opinion and some unbiased, non-sponsored research.
In "living this lifestyle" along with my years of school in biochemistry, anatomy, physiology, and pathophysiology, I know a few things about the human body and how it works...and about how my human body has responded to exercise and real food.
I've tried three of the four companies and was not impressed by any of them.
I have a long way to go on my journey, but I've already come pretty far without the help of additives. I think people sometimes want an easy solution, and that's not realistic.
If you choose to drink/eat this stuff, more power to you! I've just been asked repeatedly why I don't, and growing increasingly frustrated with all the propaganda that comes my way from well-meaning friends. Just like the clothes you wear, totally your choice. Just 100% not for me. :)
Finally...
Just because it's vegan doesn't mean it's healthy. Oreos are vegan.
Just because its organic doesn't mean it's healthy. There are organic cigarettes.
EAT REAL FOOD.
